Asset management market
As a recent report1 noted, changes in technology, asset performance, and customer preferences leave many players in the industry with unsustainable business models. Some may be able to make the required changes organically, but M&A will often be the more attractive option. It concludes that deal activity will likely accelerate both in quantity and magnitude with deals becoming larger and often cross-border.
At the same time it says the distribution of asset management is changing as intermediaries consolidate and firms move towards direct distribution. Small and mid-size asset managers typically have an incomplete product offering, a partial distribution network, or both. Their profits are being squeezed which makes them attractive targets.
Leading global players may also wish to take advantage of the falling market share of bank units which provide mostly in-house wealth management services, and of the fact that banks are increasingly considering their wealth management units as non-core activities.
Top ten asset managers in Europe, by mutual funds net flows
|Asset Manager||2016 net flows ($bn)||Cumulative share of total market net flows (%)||Cumulative share of net flows of players with positive net flows (%)||Passive share of total flows per firm (%)|
Source: The Boston Consulting Group – Global Asset Management 2017: The Investor’s Advantage
Note: Analysis excludes money market funds
Aberdeen Asset Management merged with Standard Life to form one of the world’s largest investment companies with assets under administration of €737bn. Standard Life has around 4.5 million customers and is based primarily in the UK, with operations in Ireland and Germany. More than one in six people auto-enrolled into a workplace pension in the UK have a Standard Life workplace pension. The companies first announced plans for an all-share merger in early 2017 to cut costs and gain scale.
Mattioli Woods has made a number of acquisitions, including MC Trustees and Amati Global Investors, while the Succession Group has also bought dozens of firms. Most recently it bought four businesses from its affiliated membership – Prosperitas Independent Financial Advisers, Sigma Asset Management, Norris and Fisher Independent Financial Services and Tim Burton – which added €593m to its funds under management.
A notable deal saw real estate investment manager Patrizia Immobilien acquire Triuva, the institutional fund management business of IVG Immobilien, in a deal which increased assets under management by nearly 50%. The merger creates a €30bn-plus European property fund manager and strengthens the combined group’s European network, broadening its range of products and services.
Equance, one of the largest French wealth management firms, acquired Elmlinger Patrimoine Conseil, a wealth management and social protection firm. The deal consolidates Equance’s presence in Paris.
Other deals saw La Financière d’Orion acquire financial advisory services firm GLR Consultants, and Océanic Finance acquire IPCA Immobilière Patrimoine Conseil Assurance SARL which provides wealth management and advisory services.
Phoenix Management acquired Formuesforvaltning which provides wealth management solutions in the Nordic area. Another deal saw ABG Sundal Collier Holding ASA acquire Vika Project Finance which provides advisory to clients for investment in the real estate market. Securities company Coeli, which offers private banking and wealth management services, acquired Swedish firm Mobilis Kapitalförvaltning.
PE investor Hellman & Friedman and GIC, Singapore’s sovereign wealth fund, acquired financial technology business Allfunds Bank from Intesa Sanpaolo Group, Santander Group, General Atlantic and Warburg Pincus. The deal valued Allfunds at €1.8bn. More international investors are paying attention to Spanish companies with €1-3bn assets under management, particularly French and UK investors. Domestic wealth management companies are continuing to expand in what they consider their natural markets, such as Latin America and Portugal.
Amundi acquired Pioneer Investments, the asset management business of Italian bank UniCredit, for €3.5bn. The deal brought a further €222bn of assets under Amundi’s control making it one of the world’s largest investment managers.
Ireland’s leading players – Cantor Fitzgerald, Goodbody and the Davy Group – have all been very active in acquiring smaller firms, at the same time as a number of international banks have exited the Irish wealth management sector. For instance, Davy acquired Danske bank’s discretionary wealth management business, while Cantor Fitzgerald acquired financial group Rabo Direct.
M&A across the Independent Financial Adviser (IFA) continues to be very strong. In particular, the market is seeing ongoing consolidation driven by smaller companies being forced out of the market by regulatory pressure. Large IFAs are looking to create value through synergies such as central office consolidations, while most market consolidators are seeking to move up the average client investment curve in segments where clients can afford to pay premiums for more sophisticated financial advisory services and where there is more scope for cross-selling of products.
AFH Financial Group is one of many UK groups that has been on a major acquisition spree in recent years. The firm now has more than €2.3bn of funds under management and recent acquisitions include Parker Sage Independent Financial Advisers and Eunisure. AFH recently completed a follow-on €20m equity offering.
Sanlam acquired Tavistock Financial’s network of 158 financial advisers. The advisers join Sanlam’s team of 60 financial planners and expand the Group’s reach across the UK. The acquisition added €1.7bn to Sanlam UK’s assets under advice.
Embark Group and Mazars announced a JV combining their employee benefits consultancy arms under the new Vested brand.
Bellpenny and Ascot Lloyd merged and are now trading under the unified Ascot Lloyd brand. The newly formed group is advising on over €6.8bn of clients’ funds.
Old Mutual Wealth acquired IFA Dodd Murray in a deal which added €234.0m in assets under advice.
1: Boston Consulting Group – Global Asset Management 2017: The Innovator’s Advantage